Update: TechCrunch is weighing in on this too.
Netflix CEO, Reed Hastings, has a big issue with how Comcast registers internet usage on Netflix, HBO Go and Hulu VS using the Comcast Xfinity app. In essence, here’s what is his issue: (here’s CNET’s report)
When I watch video on my Xbox from three of these four apps [Netflix, HBO Go, Hulu], it counts against my Comcast internet cap. When I watch through Comcast’s Xfinity app, however, it does not count against my Comcast internet cap. (source: Hasting’s Facebook Post)
What is Comcast’s argument? Comcast notes that using the Xfinity Xbox app won’t use up the 250 GB monthly cap (WHICH IS A LOT) because the content is not streamed over the internet, but instead is stored within Comcast’s hardware (much like OnDemand services). This seems to justify why data usage isn’t used with Xfinity, but is it fair that other apps use up the monthly data usage?
To be frank, the 250 GB limit is A LOT. Netflix CEO said he used up 1 GB of cap by watching an episode of Saturday Night Live (which was probably an hour’s worth of data). Essentially, a person can watch 250 episodes of Saturday Night Live and barely reach the cap. Yes, many people use their internet for email, internet browsing and YouTube, but still 250 GB is a lot.
Now…aside form that, is it fair what Comcast is doing? I say YES! This gives Comcast the competitive edge and incentive to use their apps. Makes complete sense and is 100% fair. Comcast’s prices are high enough, customers would freak if this were not the case. It’s all about incentives to use Comcast’s app and to stick with their service.
Perhaps other companies like Netflix/Hulu/HBO Go should focus their time and effort on figuring out how to use less internet data usage…that will be time well spent and make their existing customers happy. In fact here’s what the other apps should focus on:
- How can they deliver content faster and easier to customers?
- How can they use less data with their services?
- How can they offer more competitive pricing?
- Perhaps the apps can join forces and provide “group” prescriptions and fight against the Comcast giant
Am I missing something?
Here’s some more information about the legalities of this subject.